Why Do Some Dogs Have a Natural Instinct to Herd? Understanding the Genetics and History Behind This Behavior

Dogs are known for their amazing abilities to do a variety of tasks. One of the most fascinating things is their natural instinct to herd. Herding dogs have been bred for centuries to help farmers and ranchers manage their livestock. They are highly intelligent and trainable, making them great working dogs.

But why do some dogs have a natural instinct to herd? It all goes back to their ancestry. Dogs are descendants of wolves, and wolves are pack animals that hunt in groups. They have a natural instinct to work together to capture prey. Over time, humans began to selectively breed dogs for specific traits, including herding ability. This led to the development of many different breeds of herding dogs, each with their own unique set of skills.

Herding behavior is ingrained in some breeds more than others. For example, Border Collies are known for their intense focus and drive to herd, while other breeds like Australian Shepherds and Corgis also have strong herding instincts. Understanding why dogs have this natural instinct to herd can help us appreciate their unique abilities and provide them with the training and work they need to thrive.

History of Herding Dogs

Herding dogs have been bred for centuries to help humans manage and control livestock. The earliest records of using dogs for herding date back to ancient times, where they were used for hunting and guarding livestock. In the Middle Ages, various breeds were developed specifically for herding purposes, such as the Border Collie, the German Shepherd, and the Australian Cattle Dog.

During the 19th century, the Industrial Revolution led to a surge in demand for wool and meat, and herding dogs became increasingly important for managing large flocks efficiently. As a result, breeders began to focus on developing dogs with specific herding traits, such as intelligence, obedience, and stamina.

Today, herding dogs are still widely used in agriculture and ranching, but they have also become popular as pets and in various dog sports, such as agility and obedience competitions. Despite their long history of working with humans, herding dogs still retain their natural instincts to herd and may exhibit herding behavior even in a non-working environment.

Genetics of Herding Instinct

Herding instinct is a complex behavior that is influenced by both genetic and environmental factors. While herding dogs have been selectively bred for their ability to herd, research has shown that the herding instinct is not limited to just herding breeds. Many breeds, including terriers, hounds, and even some toy breeds, have been known to exhibit herding behavior.

Studies have shown that the herding instinct is likely controlled, at least in part, at the genetic level. Recent research has identified several genes that may play a role in the development of herding behavior. For example, a study published in Frontiers in Veterinary Science found that several genes associated with neurological development and behavior were significantly associated with herding behavior in Border Collies.

However, it is important to note that genetics alone do not determine whether a dog will exhibit herding behavior. Environmental factors, such as training and socialization, also play a significant role in the development of herding behavior. Dogs that are not exposed to livestock or given the opportunity to practice their herding skills may not exhibit the behavior, even if they have the genetic predisposition for it.

Behavioral Characteristics of Herding Dogs

Herding dogs are a unique group of canines that have been selectively bred over generations to perform specific tasks. As a result of their breeding, herding dogs have developed certain behavioral characteristics that set them apart from other breeds. Here are some of the most notable behavioral characteristics of herding dogs:

  • Instinctual drive to move animals: Herding dogs possess a strong instinctual drive to move animals around. This behavior is a result of their breeding, which was focused on developing dogs that could help with livestock management.
  • High energy levels: Herding dogs are known for their high energy levels. They need to be active and engaged to be happy and healthy.
  • Intelligence: Herding dogs are highly intelligent and trainable. They are able to learn complex tasks and respond well to positive reinforcement training methods.
  • Strong work ethic: Herding dogs have a strong work ethic and are happiest when they have a job to do. They thrive on having a purpose and being useful.
  • Protective: Many herding dogs are naturally protective of their family and property. This behavior is a result of their breeding, which required them to protect livestock from predators.

Overall, herding dogs are a unique group of canines with a strong instinctual drive to move animals, high energy levels, intelligence, a strong work ethic, and a natural protective nature. These behavioral characteristics make them excellent working dogs, but they can also make them challenging pets for inexperienced owners who are not prepared to meet their needs.

Training and Working with Herding Dogs

Herding dogs have a strong instinct to work and need to be physically and mentally active. To keep them happy and healthy, they need plenty of exercise and mental stimulation. Here are some tips for training and working with herding dogs:

  • Provide plenty of exercise: Herding dogs need plenty of exercise to burn off their energy. They enjoy running, chasing, and playing games like fetch. A daily walk or run is not enough. These dogs need more intense exercise like hiking, agility training, or herding trials.
  • Challenge their minds: Herding dogs are intelligent and need mental stimulation. They enjoy tasks like obedience training, trick training, and puzzle toys. They also enjoy working on a farm or ranch, where they can use their herding instincts to move livestock.
  • Use positive reinforcement: Herding dogs respond well to positive reinforcement. Reward them with treats, praise, and playtime when they do something right. Avoid punishment or harsh training methods, as this can harm the dog’s confidence and trust.
  • Socialize them early: Herding dogs can be wary of strangers and other animals. Socialize them early by exposing them to different people, animals, and environments. This will help them become well-adjusted and confident adults.
  • Find a job for them: Herding dogs need a job to do. They enjoy working on a farm or ranch, but they can also excel in other activities like search and rescue, therapy work, or obedience trials.

Remember that herding dogs have a strong instinct to work and need plenty of exercise and mental stimulation. By providing them with plenty of opportunities to work and play, you can help them live a happy and fulfilling life.


Herding is an instinctual behavior in dogs that has been bred into certain breeds over time. The herding behavior is a result of the dog’s natural instincts to control and move livestock. While not all dogs have a herding instinct, those that do can be trained to use their instincts in a variety of ways.

Dogs that have a herding instinct can be great working dogs, as they excel in tasks that require control, focus, and stamina. However, it’s important to remember that herding dogs need to be trained properly and given plenty of exercise and mental stimulation to keep them happy and healthy.

If you’re considering getting a herding dog, it’s important to do your research and make sure you’re prepared for the unique needs and challenges that come with owning a dog with a strong herding instinct. With proper training and care, a herding dog can be a loyal and loving companion that will bring joy and excitement to your life.

You may also like...